About Us

Protecting Futures

We have years of insurance experience helping clients prepare for the unknown. Ask us about:






We can access many different insurance products so you can get the right one for you.

Assessing Need

 Insurance is more than products, services, or rates... it's a matter of trust.
At Prey Insurance Services, LLC customers are our most important product.
Clients who place their business in our hands trust us to manage their coverage
programs fairly and efficiently. 

Building Relationships

Everyone has different insurance needs. We continually earn that trust by building long-term relationships with
companies, individuals, and businesses like yours.  

Our Team

Mike Prey, President, Owner, Licensed Producer

Mike has been employed at the agency since 1999, where he started by filing paperwork, taking pictures and measuring buildings. He received his Property, Casualty, and Life insurance licenses in 2005. In 2006, Mike graduated from UW-Stevens Point with a degree in Business Administration. Mike purchased the agency from his parents in 2014. He achieved his Certified Insurance Service Representation designation from The National Alliance. Mike is lifelong Shawano resident. He and his wife Erin have two children, Maddin and Saylor. Mike enjoys golfing, hunting, sports, boating and traveling. 

Dave Prey

Dave began his insurance career...

Chris Prey

Chris does this......

Samantha Senzig, Personal line Customer Service Representative

Samantha has been employed at the agency since 2013. She is a lifelong resident of Shawano and is enrolled part-time at UW-GB working on her degree in Business Administration. She specializes in assisting clients, customer relations and creating quotes. Samantha and her significant other, Dillon, have a rescue dog named Byron. They enjoy four-wheeling, horseback riding with their horses, Ellie and Asher, and snowmobiling.

Jim Geenen

Jim does this......

Matt Beyer

Something interesting  Matt

Bethany Watters, Customer Services Representative

Bethany rejoined the agency in 2017. She has a degree in Marketing from UW-Oshkosh and is a licensed Customer Service Representative. Bethany specializes in assisting current and future clients. She has 5 children and teaches religious education for children at her church. She enjoys spending time outdoors with her boyfriend, Andy, and her family. 

The Prey Insurance Services, LLC team is here to help you every step of the way.  We'll answer your questions, provide you with a free quote, help you with your insurance claim and anything else needed to ensure that you are receiving the very best. 


Contact Us

Contact Us for a Free Quote

Prey Insurance Services, LLC

1411 S. Main St. Shawano, WI 54166

(715) 526-2515 (715)526-3140 fax


Monday - Friday: 8:00 am - 4:30 pm

Saturday: By Appointment

Sunday: Closed

Email US